Recruitment FAIL!
By Melissa Lourenco | November 3, 2009
In my last post, Passing the Recuitment Process, I went through some suggestions for interview candidates, based on what we like to see during the hiring process.
Some were pretty basic, but having seen just about everything when recruiting, I thought it might also be a constructive exercise to share some examples of what not to do. (These all really happened, folks.)
- In a resume listing referees, don’t include a note stating “I love where I work right now so please do not contact them because I don’t want to tip them off that I’m looking around”. Just don’t include them as referees, ok?
- In the cover letter, don’t say “I know it may look like I move around a bit but it is important to note that I’ve never resigned”.
- Try, if you can, not to get your mother to write the cover letter. It may be a glowing letter of recommendation, but sentences like “recruitment is like dating and my son would make the ‘marriage’ work” can make interviewers slightly queasy.
- Under the Awards and Achievements section, avoid listing television appearances like “Been a contestant on The Price is Right”.
- Including salary expectations can be helpful; putting “The higher the better” is not.
- By all means, include any medical information that might be pertinent, but not that you have “minor allergies to stupid people and teenage girls who like, say ‘like’ a lot”.
- Take the iPod earphones out of your ears when entering the interview (though responding with “It proves that I can multitask” when this is pointed out is not bad).
- If you really feel the job is not for you, feel free to say so honestly and with a smile. Don’t excuse yourself in the middle of the interview, say you’re going to the bathroom and never return.
- Before the interview commences, don’t use your camera phone to take a photo of the startled HR Manager and say that it’s “Just so I can remember which people I have seen today”.
- Don’t use the letterhead from your current employer on your cover letter.
- You will be asked “What are your weaknesses?” Try to come up with something better than “I find it hard to get up in the mornings so I sometimes turn up late”.
- Yes, some habits are hard to break. But chewing your nails throughout the entire interview, and spitting out bits as you go will simply not do. Wear gloves.
Honestly, the ultimate advice I can give you is try to stand to out without standing out for the wrong reasons. If in doubt, use your common sense and put yourself in the employer’s shoes — think of things that would impress (do the research) and “always” be professional.
Tell us your own recruitment interview horror stories in the Talkback section below!
More from “Aussie Rules”
Talkback 7 Talkbacks
RE: Recruitment FAIL!
Loves it! Ones I have had.
1) guy who proceeded 1/2 thru interview to eat his lunch - he has to eat every day at 12.30 ALWAYS.
2) lady with a basic instinct leg crossing action.
3) phantom farter - dude there were 2 of us in the room.
4) resumes spelt in correctly - I went on a typing cause, or suburb of "stratified" instead of strathfield.
1) guy who proceeded 1/2 thru interview to eat his lunch - he has to eat every day at 12.30 ALWAYS.
2) lady with a basic instinct leg crossing action.
3) phantom farter - dude there were 2 of us in the room.
4) resumes spelt in correctly - I went on a typing cause, or suburb of "stratified" instead of strathfield.
molly_baker69
11/09/2009 04:41 PM
RE: Recruitment FAIL!
@molly_baker
Saying 'resumes spelt in correctly' and then spelling "incorrectly" wrong yourself would be also be classed as a fail.
Saying 'resumes spelt in correctly' and then spelling "incorrectly" wrong yourself would be also be classed as a fail.
sas_101
11/09/2009 07:19 PM
RE: Recruitment FAIL!
Thanks molly_baker69 for sharing your experience!
Keep them coming!!
Keep them coming!!
Meli55a
11/09/2009 07:44 PM
jonathan villamor
AFTER I READ ALL THIS I LEARN A LOT WHAT TO DO ABOUT MY SELF ABOUT HOW TO APPLY AND WHAT IS THE RIGHT WAY TO IN PROVED OUR SELF DURING THE INTERVIEW.
Jonathan Vivante C. Villamor
01/13/2010 05:23 PM
RE: Recruitment FAIL!
I can honestly say that I have not been guilty of any of these inappropriate behaviours. However, As an interviewee, I have been asked if I was married. When I stated that this was not an appropriate question and I was not legally required to respond the (male) interviewer said: "So does that mean you aren't going to tell me whether you are married? ". I stated that it was obvious to me that we had different value systems and that I was terminating the interview. I promptly left.
ppines2213
01/19/2010 03:58 AM
RE: Recruitment FAIL!
I had a person that I was interviewing for a position as a Team Leader of Payroll and HR Services and when I asked why she wanted the position she responded with "I like to make people happy", right interesting given it's a technical role... When I asked her why she choose to study in HR she responded with "I like to make people happy", ok... When I asked her what motivates her and keeps her engaged, she said (yep you guessed it), "Making people happy"... After about 10 responses of 'Making people happy', consequently I didn't make her happy by giving her the job and would have to suggest that she tries a different career... perhaps the Escort Business?
mholland@...
01/19/2010 06:54 PM
Bree
I think #1 is an absolute minefield though! Of course you want to mention your latest references but surely the interviewer should be able to show discretion! We don't all want to advertise that we are looking for a different job.
I've seen the situation where someone has been on the hunt for a new job unbeknown to the current employer. The interviewer decided to be proactive and made a cold call to the business (she had not listed anyone from her current job as a reference as she was worried her job would be in jeopardy).
Her current manager was unimpressed at the situation and gave a very poor reference siting lack of loyalty and selfishness etc. She didn't get the new job and she lost her current.
It's one thing to do things right as an interviewee - but the interviewer needs some rules to follow too!!
I've seen the situation where someone has been on the hunt for a new job unbeknown to the current employer. The interviewer decided to be proactive and made a cold call to the business (she had not listed anyone from her current job as a reference as she was worried her job would be in jeopardy).
Her current manager was unimpressed at the situation and gave a very poor reference siting lack of loyalty and selfishness etc. She didn't get the new job and she lost her current.
It's one thing to do things right as an interviewee - but the interviewer needs some rules to follow too!!
Breezle
03/21/2010 06:15 PM









